What happens if I throw legendary fish back? (2024)

So if you catch a legendary bass or something then throw it back you can keep catching them until you get one large enough for your liking, since I've had a few 3 pound legendary that are kinda wimpy. So if you want some monster 10 lb fish then throw it back and don't keep it.

Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Can I catch legendary fish again?

Tiller. Sub idea: if you free the legendary fish in the water, you can catch it immediately again. if you sell it, you can catch it next year.

Takedown request View complete answer on forums.stardewvalley.net

Should I keep the legendary fish rdr2?

Once you've caught a Legendary Fish, store it on your horse and immediately head to the nearest post office. Keeping the catch on your horse, you can mail it to Jeremy Gill. After 24 hours, you'll receive your reward for you fish. Make sure to be incredibly careful when transporting the fish.

Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

Can you catch legendary fish again in rdr2?

Legendary Fish can only be caught once each per playthrough. Move the line with the left analog stick when a fish is splashing, to avoid snapping the line.

Takedown request View complete answer on eurogamer.net

What to do with legendary fish once caught?

Sell them or put them in an aquarium (you only get one legendary fish of each per save, if you sell it it is gone). I make them into sashimi and eat them to gain their strength. You can put the in a fish tank and they'll swim around and be very cool!

Takedown request View complete answer on reddit.com

Kieran's reaction if Arthur throws the Legendary Fish back into the lake

Is there any reason to keep legendary fish?

You can only ever catch each Legendary Fish once. Obviously one option is selling it, as Legendary Fish bring a high price. But since the update, you can put your fish in fish tanks and it might be interesting to put your legendary fish aside for the decoration of your house in the future.

Can I put legendary fish in the Fish Pond?

Legendary Fish cannot be placed in a fish pond, which means that they will not produce roe. Additionally, the following creatures that can be placed in a fish pond will not produce roe.

Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

What is the easiest Legendary Fish to get to in rdr2?

The Legendary Smallmouth Bass is one of the easiest to get to. It's in lake Owanjila just to the west of Strawberry. Use the Special Lake Lure to catch it.

Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

Can you catch the final legendary catfish rdr2?

Actually, the game files have two different channel catfish, so it's possible that Rockstar did indeed intend to do something more with the bottom-feeder, but perhaps the final content got cut. Alas, the channel catfish remains but a myth, never to be caught.

Takedown request View complete answer on polygon.com

Can you get the legendary catfish rdr2?

The Legendary Bullhead Catfish is one of 13 Legendary Fish that can be caught in Red Dead Redemption 2. You may catch it independently or as part of the Stranger quest A Fisher of Fish.

Takedown request View complete answer on ign.com

How many Legendary Animals can you get as Arthur?

Red Dead Redemption 2 Legendary Animals requirements and preparation. There are a total of 16 Legendary Animals in Red Dead Redemption 2, but only 10 of them can be found and hunted in the wild once you complete Chapter One and leave the mountain.

Takedown request View complete answer on eurogamer.net

Is it worth hunting the Legendary Animals in RDR2?

Hunting legendary animals can be pretty fun. It's much more relaxing, depending on the animal, and you can go about it however you like. If you're interested in replaying the game from the beginning and want to curtail some annoying little features, hunt down these animals to save yourself any future hassles.

Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

What to do if you lose a legendary fish in RDR2?

Yeah, if you lose a legendary fish after catching it, just wait two days and it should respawn. Lost legendary animal pelts automatically get transported to the trapper though.

Takedown request View complete answer on gamefaqs.gamespot.com

How many times can you catch the legend fish?

For the achievement, see Achievements. The Legend is a Fish that can be caught during Spring in The Mountain lake during rainy weather. It is one of the five Legendary Fish, so it can only be caught once per save file, or once per player in Multiplayer.

Takedown request View complete answer on stardewvalleywiki.com

Is legendary fish rare?

Stardew Valley's Legendary fish are the hardest to catch in the game, and many have certain requirements players must fulfill to find them.

Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

What is the hardest fish to catch in RDR2?

From rival gang members and law enforcement to wild cougars, bears, and alligators, players will need to be on their toes when exploring the environment, even while on missions with fellow members of the Van der Linde gang, but the legendary bullhead catfish in RDR2 is one of the most challenging.

Takedown request View complete answer on screenrant.com

What is the hardest Legendary Fish in RDR2?

Legendary Bullhead Catfish

Easily the most annoying fish to catch, the Bullhead Catfish resides across a whole body of water on the landlocked island that houses Sisika Penitentiary. You will need a rowboat to get across which you can find on the outskirts of the swamplands north of Saint-Denis.

Takedown request View complete answer on gamesradar.com

What Legendary Fish is hard to catch RDR2?

Fishing for legendary fish can take much more time than normal, and it's important to stay patient. If you've spent five minutes in one area and nothing has happened, draw the line back and move to a different spot. As long as it's within the correct area, you'll be fine.

Takedown request View complete answer on redbull.com

What is the rarest non legendary animal in RDR2?

The panther is probably the hardest non-legendary animal to hunt in Red Dead Redemption 2. It's rare, quick, and deadly.

Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

What is the best fish to sell in RDR2?

If you're fishing to make money, then you should be looking for sockeye salmon specifically. These guys have a price of $4.25 in Valentine, New Hanover, and West Elizabeth, or $5.31 in St. Denis, Rhodes, Blackwater, and Tumbleweed.

Takedown request View complete answer on thegamer.com

What is the strongest legendary animal in RDR2?

The bullgator is the strongest animal in the game, so we advise sniping it from a distance using the Rolling Block Rifle. Just be warned the monster will charge you… and it's terrifyingly quick.

Takedown request View complete answer on gamesradar.com

What is the best bait for legendary fish rdr2?

You need a special kind of bait

To be able to catch the legendary fish, you won't simply be able to use any old bait. There are three types of special bait/lures that you can purchase for $20 each in Lagras. Each one is specific to a type of water; the special river lure, special lake lure, and special swamp lure.

Takedown request View complete answer on redbull.com

Can you wild bait for legendary fish?

Effect. Using Wild Bait with your fishing rod reduces the delay before a nibble by 62.5%. There is also a chance to catch two fish, equal to 0.25 + Daily Luck / 2.0. The chance to catch 2 fish does not apply to Legendary Fish.

Takedown request View complete answer on stardewcommunitywiki.com

Is Legendary fishing a good game?

It's fun in an arcade-esque way and is an ok way to waste 30 mins. Fun but simple fishing game. My 5 year old liked it too.

Takedown request View complete answer on metacritic.com

Previous question
How old was Hosea in rdr2 when he died?

Next question
What happens if you fail a key in wow?

What happens if I throw legendary fish back? (2024)

FAQs

Should I throw back legendary fish rdr2? ›

So if you catch a legendary bass or something then throw it back you can keep catching them until you get one large enough for your liking, since I've had a few 3 pound legendary that are kinda wimpy. So if you want some monster 10 lb fish then throw it back and don't keep it.

Can you catch legendary fish again? ›

The Legend is a fish that can be caught during Spring in the Mountain lake during rainy weather. It is one of the five Legendary Fish, so it can only be caught once per save file, or once per player in Multiplayer.

What happens if you don't mail legendary fish? ›

Yeah, if you lose a legendary fish after catching it, just wait two days and it should respawn. Lost legendary animal pelts automatically get transported to the trapper though. "Holy Roller sits in the garden we fled.

Can I catch legendary fish twice in RDR2? ›

Legendary Fish can only be caught once each per playthrough. Move the line with the left analog stick when a fish is splashing, to avoid snapping the line.

What happens when you throw a fish back? ›

Unfortunately, people who practice “catch and release” cause no less harm to fish than do other anglers. Fish who are caught and then returned to the water suffer such severe physiological stress that they often die of shock, or their injuries may make them easy targets for predators.

What happens when you catch all 13 legendary fish? ›

Once you've caught and mailed all 13 Legendary Fish, you will receive an invitation from Jeremy Gill, who invites the player out for one final fishing trip before the quest concludes. We'll leave it there to avoid spoilers, but trust us, this one is worth the hours spent getting your shins wet.

Are there 13 or 15 legendary fish in RDR2? ›

There are 13 Legendary Fish to catch throughout the world of Red Dead Redemption 2. You can obtain a map with the locations of all of the fish by speaking to Jeremy Gill and starting the Stranger quest A Fisher of Fish on the pier along the northeast shore of Flat Iron Lake.

Has anyone caught the legendary channel catfish in RDR2? ›

Actually, the game files have two different channel catfish, so it's possible that Rockstar did indeed intend to do something more with the bottom-feeder, but perhaps the final content got cut. Alas, the channel catfish remains but a myth, never to be caught.

Can you catch 2 legendary fish with wild bait? ›

The chance of catching 2 fish does not apply to Legendary Fish. It can however, catch 2 of the semi-Legendary fish caught from the Extended Family quest line. Wild Bait can be crafted after being taught the recipe by Linus during his 4-heart cutscene.

How many legendary fish can Arthur get? ›

There are a total of thirteen legendary fish in RDR2. Each of these fish are larger and rarer than their non-legendary counterparts. Players will have to catch each of these fish to complete the "A Fisher of Fish" quest. To start the quest, people will need to speak with Jeremy Gill.

Why won't Legendary fish appear? ›

You need a special kind of bait

To be able to catch the legendary fish, you won't simply be able to use any old bait. There are three types of special bait/lures that you can purchase for $20 each in Lagras. Each one is specific to a type of water; the special river lure, special lake lure, and special swamp lure.

Is there any reason to keep legendary fish? ›

Having even one Legendary Fish, let alone all of them, is arguably symbolic of a Farmer's skill and dedication to fishing. Because of this, combined with their unique designs, it makes perfect sense to keep them on display rather than selling them.

What to do with legendary fish once caught RDR2? ›

Once you've caught a Legendary Fish, store it on your horse and immediately head to the nearest post office. Keeping the catch on your horse, you can mail it to Jeremy Gill. After 24 hours, you'll receive your reward for you fish. Make sure to be incredibly careful when transporting the fish.

Should you keep the legendary fish? ›

Having even one Legendary Fish, let alone all of them, is arguably symbolic of a Farmer's skill and dedication to fishing. Because of this, combined with their unique designs, it makes perfect sense to keep them on display rather than selling them.

Should I sell legendary fish RDR2? ›

You should be able to earn significantly more by catching the legendary fish compared to the three-stared fish that Kerbert mentioned, however, you shouldn't get your hopes to high. There are certainly better ways to earn some sweet cash.

Should I throw carp back? ›

While you can throw him back in, most feel that once they have rid the water of a carp they do not want to put him back. This leaves you the option of taking it home. If you are not going to eat it, the best thing to do is to use it for fertilizer for some tree or other plant on your property.

Top Articles
Journal articles: 'Zi yang shu yuan' – Grafiati
Impact Gardens Cbd Gummies | HOAIC
Helicopter Over Massapequa Now
19 Awesome Things to Do in Redmond, Oregon
Wowhead Filling The Cages
Does Teddy Swims Have A Wife? Exploring The Life Of The Rising Star
Giant Egg Classic Wow
Stockton (California) – Travel guide at Wikivoyage
Estate Sales Net Grand Rapids
Tacos Diego Hugoton Ks
For My Derelict Favorite Novel Online
Scholar Dollar Nmsu
Twitchxx.com
Comcast Business Sign In
Clemson Sorority Rankings 2022
Elisabeth Fuchs, Conductor : Magazine : salzburg.info
Belle Fourche Landfill
Roses Gordon Highway
Descargar AI Video Editor - Size Reducer para PC - LDPlayer
Rooms For Rent Portland Oregon Craigslist
Craigslist Hoosick Falls
The Quiet Girl Showtimes Near Amc Shirlington 7
Papa's Games Unblocked Games
Amy Riley Electric Video
Icdrama Hong Kong Drama
Ups Store Pineville La
Theramed Junior Strawberry 6+ Tandpasta 75 ml - 12 stuks - Voordeelverpakking | bol
Staar English 2 2022 Answer Key
Goodwill Winter Springs 434
Burlington Spectrum Tucson
By Association Only Watsonville
Mark Rosen announces his departure from WCCO-TV after 50-year career
Unblocked Games 66E
Www.questdiagnostics.com
Official Klj
Thomas E Schneider Jeopardy
O2 eSIM guide | Download your eSIM | The Drop
Craigslist Hart Mi
Liv Morgan Wedgie
Hood County Buy Sell And Trade
Dom Tradingview
NUROFEN Junior Fieber-u.Schmerzsaft Oran.40 mg/ml - Beipackzettel
Matt Laubhan Salary
11526 Lake Ave Cleveland Oh 44102
Meggen Nut
Craigslist Pelham Al
Vidant My Chart Login
Keystyle.hensel Phelps.com/Account/Login
Www.888Tt.xyz
Potassium | History, Uses, Facts, Physical & Chemical Characteristics
Jetblue Flight Status & Tracker
Platform Overview - Aria Systems
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Last Updated:

Views: 6494

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Birthday: 1998-02-19

Address: 64841 Delmar Isle, North Wiley, OR 74073

Phone: +17844167847676

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: LARPing, Kitesurfing, Sewing, Digital arts, Sand art, Gardening, Dance

Introduction: My name is Amb. Frankie Simonis, I am a hilarious, enchanting, energetic, cooperative, innocent, cute, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.